Summary of Offense:
On July 8, 1991, Stokley and Randy Brazeal kidnapped two 13-year-old girls near Elfrida in Cochise County and took them to a remote area, where they raped them. Fearing the consequences, they agreed to kill the girls and each man strangled one of the girls. To ensure that the victims were dead, Stokley repeatedly stomped on them and stabbed each of them in the right eye. Stokley and Brazeal then threw the bodies down a water-filled mine shaft.